Listening To You - Lacanian Psychoanalysis and Psychotherapy in London
  • Welcome
  • Listening
  • Psychoanalysis
  • The Therapist
  • Beginning therapy
  • Code Of Practice
  • Contact Details
  • Links
  • A Psychoanalyst's Blog

Derek Hook interviews Christos Tombras, part 3

3/4/2025

0 Comments

 
I’m sharing transcripts from a discussion I had with Derek Hook in December 2021 for his YouTube Channel. We discussed Heidegger, Lacanian psychoanalysis and my book, Discourse Ontology. What follows is the transcript of our conversation, very slightly edited for clarity.

For the actual video (part 3), see here:
For part 1 and 2 of the transcription click here and here.
Part 3:
Heidegger's concept of 'das Man' (the They) can be both compared to - and contrasted with - Lacan's idea of the big Other. One crucial related idea, as Christos Tombras notes, is that the distinction between the ontic and the ontological (which is of course so crucial to Heidegger), is rejected by Lacan. The project of a Discourse Ontology, as outlined by Tombras, includes the attempt to formalize Lacanian concepts, to formulate the philosophical background of the account of the human subject as developed by Lacan. (DH) 

Read More
0 Comments

Derek Hook interviews Christos Tombras, part 2

3/4/2025

0 Comments

 
I’m sharing transcripts from a discussion I had with Derek Hook in December 2021 for his YouTube Channel. We discussed Heidegger, Lacanian psychoanalysis and my book, Discourse Ontology. What follows is the transcript of our conversation, very slightly edited for clarity.

For the actual video (part 2), see here:
For part 1 and 3 of the transcription click here and here.
Part 2:
How should we position both Lacan and Heidegger in relation to the project of ontology?  Is it the case that ontology might play a crucial role in furthering a Lacanian agenda, despite Lacan's own rejection of ontology? Stressing both incompatibilities and prospective overlaps between these two thinkers, Christos Tombras offers illuminating perspectives on these questions. Tombras also discusses the concept of discourse in Lacan's thought, before moving on to emphasize the role of truth (
aletheia) in Heidegger's philosophy alongside the role of primal affirmation (Bejahung) in Freud. Can we claim that there are moments where Freud is a Heideggerian without knowing it? (DH)

Read More
0 Comments

Derek Hook interviews Christos Tombras, part 1

3/4/2025

0 Comments

 
I’m sharing transcripts from a discussion I had with Derek Hook in December 2021 for his YouTube Channel. We discussed Heidegger, Lacanian psychoanalysis and my book, Discourse Ontology. What follows is the transcript of our conversation, very slightly edited for clarity.
​
For the actual video (part 1), see here:
For part 2 and 3 of the transcription click here and here.
Part 1:
What are the benefits of reading Lacan alongside Heidegger, and Heidegger alongside Lacan? Christos Tombras, Lacanian psychoanalyst and author of Discourse Ontology (Palgrave, 2019), offers his reflections on this question. Further questions emerge. How are we to use Heidegger today, given his association with the Nazi regime? Are Lacan and Heidegger not incompatible given Lacan's commitment to a kind of (psychoanalytic) ethics as opposed to Heidegger's commitment to ontology? Furthermore: might Heidegger's value to psychoanalysis be in part the result of the critical questions he directs at Freudian psychoanalysis? (DH)
Next->
Derek Hook:
Okay, hello everyone.
It's a great pleasure today to speak to Christos Tombras, who's a colleague of mine from my time in London. And what Christos is going to be talking to us about particularly is his fantastic book, which is Discourse Ontology, Body and the Construction of a World from Heidegger through Lacan.
So it's great to have the opportunity to enter into a dialogue about certain of these topics, because one of the questions that sometimes emerges, for me at least, where I'm teaching in an institution which is friendly to phenomenology, is why should people who are well-versed in, say, Heidegger's philosophy, be at all interested in Lacan? And I think we'd be right in saying that it doesn't always seem to be the case that there are that many Heideggerians who would be interested in Lacan, so maybe our first question for Christos today then would be something like, why these two? Why this pairing? Why do we bring Heidegger to Lacan or Lacan to Heidegger? What motivated that for you in the book? Christos, if you could give us your thoughts.

Christos Tombras:
Thank you Derek. I think what one notices, reading Lacan, is that Heidegger is always present, either by name, he mentions him, or by terminology, in conventions he is using in his writing, you can see Heideggerian features all around Lacan. That creates a first question to me. Why is Lacan interested in Heidegger? And then I went into Heidegger himself, into his work, and I found that Heidegger was very critical of psychoanalysis, extremely critical actually. So this was a challenge for me to understand how Heidegger is so against psychoanalysis, and if that is the case, why is Lacan interested in Heidegger? And what made it more important for me personally, a practitioner of psychoanalysis, is that Heidegger's arguments against basic Freudian concepts are very strong, are arguments that you cannot really ignore. So it was a challenge for me to actually see how can these criticisms of Heidegger be responded to. And of course, I would call Lacan, who provides either directly or indirectly a kind of answer. So this was the starting point for me.

Read More
0 Comments

    About

    This is the blog of
    Christos Tombras
    a psychoanalyst practising
    in London.

    For more information,
    please click here.

    For a list of all posts,
    please click here.

    Archives

    April 2025
    January 2020
    May 2019
    March 2016
    October 2014
    April 2014
    May 2013
    October 2012
    February 2012
    July 2011
    June 2011
    February 2011
    September 2010
    March 2010
    February 2010
    January 2010
    December 2009
    November 2009
    October 2009
    September 2009
    August 2009


    RSS Feed


    Categories

    All
    Body Mind Dichotomy
    Books
    Brain Initiative
    Cfar
    Descartes
    Discourse Ontology
    Dsm
    Event
    Evidence
    Falsification Criterion
    Films
    Free Will
    Hard Sciences
    Health Professions Council
    History
    Immanuel Kant
    Jacques Lacan
    Jouissance
    Lanzmann
    Lecture
    Martin Heidegger
    Measuring Effectiveness
    Medical Model
    Mental Illness
    Nazism
    Nimh
    Oedipus Complex
    Phantasy
    Psychoanalysis
    Psychosis
    Randomized Control Trials
    Reality
    Regulation Of Psychotherapy
    Resistance
    Reviews
    Scientific Research
    Sexuality
    Shoah
    Sigmund Freud
    Signifier
    Stigma
    Symptoms
    Teaching
    Therapy
    The Unconscious
    Truth
    Ukcp


Listening To You • An Invitation to Talk • Lacanian Psychoanalysis • London     © 2009 - 2025